RSS Feed
25 Sep 2010
Mendenhall and Mike Williams for Moss and Stewart
I'm in a .5 points per reception league and was recently offered Randy Moss and Jonathan Stewart for Rashard Mendenhall and MIke Williams (Tampa Bay). While Stewart and Moss have underperformed so far this year I still am leaning towards doing this trade. Do you think it would be a good trade for me?
5 replies , Last at 02 Oct 2010, 3:44am by tally
Re: Mendenhall and Mike Williams for Moss and Stewart
It all depends on what the rest of your team looks like.
Re: Mendenhall and Mike Williams for Moss and Stewart
All other things equal...
Re: Mendenhall and Mike Williams for Moss and Stewart
In a vacuum, it's pretty equal, IMO. You're getting about the same point production over baseline between Mendenhall and Moss while the other two players are about replacement level.
So it depends on team composition.
Re: Mendenhall and Mike Williams for Moss and Stewart
I usually agree with Tally though I am concerned about Moss's performance over baseline given his contract situation and the fact that NE seems to be becoming more like a Sean Payton team on offense.
Re: Mendenhall and Mike Williams for Moss and Stewart
I'm also concerned, obviously, so I'm basing this a lot on what KUBIAK thinks. The primary driver in the OP's case is really team needs, as I alluded to. It's basically RB1 for WR1, which usually favors RB1, but if you're pretty good at RB and WR is a position of need, it's a fair trade.
Post new comment